In this Ask Me Anything episode we sit down again with expert SIV instructor and coach Malin Lobb to answer questions that were posed by our audience about reserve decisions, low-altitude incidents, cravat recovery, and developing reliable wing-control skills. Malin explains how configuration, height, and situational awareness affect emergency choices, and why practiced control inputs matter more than rigid rules. Malin also breaks down reserve selection, SIV instruction standards, wing-control skills, and how pilots can radically reduce their risk by controlling spins/ rotations. We also examine speed-bar technique, glider size, 2 vs 3 liners, and why pilot responses to rotations matter in serious incidents. You asked, Malin answered!
If you like what you hear, please consider becoming a subscriber to ensure our high-quality content continues. You can also help contribute to a healthier, greener planet through our partnership with Our Forest.
See our donation and subscription options here.
Listen to the Podcast
Listen to us on all the most popular podcast platforms:
Why “just throw” is sound default advice when a pilot is disoriented, with a nuanced exception when releasing a brake could accelerate a dangerous rotation. How reserve deployment time and outcome depend on the wing’s configuration, rotation, descent rate, and whether the reserve catches in the wing. The “red zone” of flying: height, skill, takeoff, landing, and ridge-running determine how much time a pilot has to recover or deploy a reserve. Malin’s advice to pull and throw the reserve in one motion, get it into clean air, and watch its deployment rather than spending critical seconds identifying rotation direction. Why a clean catch-and-release and more confident use of the full brake range can reduce cascades and the need to stall as a reset. Cravat management: stop rotation, establish a safe heading and terrain clearance, assess the cravat type, then select a suitable clearing method. How adverse roll can make a cravat spin-out easier, and why Malin describes this as an advanced technique requiring practice. Why real cravatted autorotations can require much stronger brake input than SIV practice suggests, and why pilots must prepare for a stall on exit. Malin reports two reserve deployments across nearly 4,400 SIV flights in the previous three years, crediting refined methods and preparation. Malin recommends choosing a square reserve over a round one, explaining that square designs can be oversized without the same increase in pendulum instability. Reserve choice depends on context: a steerable reserve can suit high-altitude situations with time to manage it, while a simple, fast-deploying option is preferable in low emergencies. He advocates sizing reserves with a margin, noting his recommendation to stay at least 20% below the reserve’s maximum weight range. Malin argues SIV instruction lacks consistent standards and outlines basic safety considerations, including life jackets, first-aid capability, rescue equipment, practiced procedures, and video debriefs. He says pilots should develop wing-control skills alongside cross-country distance and glider progression, rather than treating performance or hotter wings as the only measure of improvement. When flying on speed bar, Malin advises holding rear risers or B-risers instead of the brakes, since instinctive brake input during a pressure drop can contribute to a collapse. Malin says line count alone does not determine a wing’s handling or recovery; aspect ratio, design, and the wing-harness combination also matter. The conversation focuses on rotations as a major danger in paragliding and on pilot skill in preventing a glider from developing into a serious rotation. Malin describes changing his lightweight hike-and-fly setup to include a reserve and back protection after seeing how unpredictable accidents can be. For pitch training, Malin favors a lower-risk approach that teaches the needed correction without repeatedly exposing pilots to aggressive pendulums and potential whip effects.
takeaways
“If you’re completely lost, then yeah, you might as well try it.” “Height is your friend in paragliding.” “Just getting it out as quick as possible is the thing.” “What’s important is you look at the reserve handle rather than trying to feel it.” “A clean catch and release sorts that out.” “The first thing is ignore it because people just get obsessed by it.” “Stop the rotation, get a new heading and get some clearance from terrain.” “If you’re getting cravats which are half the wing, you’ve basically got no brake pressure.” “It’s a real life scenario with a cravat you will have higher pressure than you’ve ever felt before.” “You will have to pull that brake harder than you’ve ever pulled it before.” Oversize it a bit, it’s worth it. If you do want that option, I’d probably go for that one because it’s less complicated. Anytime you go on bar, grab the rear risers. Just don’t have them in your hands. If you are becoming a better pilot as you go, you can actually be a safer pilot. You can’t be too good at wind control. The smaller you go, the more aggressive, more twitchy. I don’t think we’re all in the same boat. If everyone mastered rotations, our death rate would just go down massively. You can learn pitch without exposing that whip effect.
key frameworks
The red zone Clean catch and release Cravat assessment: stop rotation, establish heading and clearance, then choose a clearing method Risk homeostasis Swiss cheese model of accident causation
action items
Practice SIV skills with a qualified instructor, including clean catch-and-release and use of the full brake range. Learn how your wing responds to different inputs and how much height different configurations can cost. If disoriented in an emergency, prioritize getting the reserve out promptly; once deployed, watch it for inflation or entanglement. Before attempting to clear a cravat, stop rotation, establish terrain clearance, and assess the type of cravat. Train specifically for the higher brake pressure and possible stall exit of a real cravatted autorotation. When selecting a reserve, consider a square design and size up within appropriate limits for your all-up flying weight. Choose a steerable reserve only when the situation and available altitude give you time to use its features; prioritize simplicity in low emergencies. Before booking SIV, ask about the instructor’s safety procedures, rescue equipment and practice, first-aid capability, life jackets, and video debriefs. When using speed bar, hold rear risers or B-risers rather than the brakes to avoid reflex brake input during pressure changes. Build wing-control skills as you progress to more demanding wings or conditions, and seek training that teaches pitch corrections without unnecessary exposure to aggressive maneuvers.
sound bites
“Oversize it a bit, it’s worth it.” “Just stop buying them guys.” “Grab the rear risers.”
Chapters
00:00 Reserve decisions after a low-altitude incident 04:33 Reserve deployment time and the limits of the red zone 09:02 Getting the reserve out, then monitoring its deployment 12:31 Why clean catch-and-release can prevent a cascade 14:45 When cravats may require a stall 16:27 Assessing a cravat before choosing a recovery method 20:55 An advanced adverse-roll technique for clearing cravats 25:59 Why pilots need the full brake range 28:12 Low collapses, ridge-running, and two-line wing control 35:20 Preparing for the force of a real cravatted autorotation 39:35 Reserve deployment practice and learning from real emergencies 41:02 Steerable versus simple reserves: matching choice to the situation 43:58 Why reserve size and square designs matter 46:15 Hike-and-fly weight savings versus safety margins 49:42 How to evaluate SIV instructors and safety procedures 55:09 Risk homeostasis, wing progression, and active control 01:00:18 Do outside rear risers improve flat turns? 01:02:05 Speed-bar technique: keep your hands off the brakes 01:05:05 Two-liners, three-liners, and what affects recovery 01:06:37 How glider size and harness pairing change handling 01:08:30 Paragliding accident risk and the role of pilot skill 01:15:28 Why Malin changed how he teaches pitch maneuvers
gavin (00:01.811)
Mallon, great to have you back on the show. I really appreciate you doing this. we're gonna hear at some point about Active Air and Pure and what you're doing and the the breakaway from Fly Yo, but I we've got a whole bunch of questions that came in on misconceptions of flying and you know, some other stuff. So I'm really excited to jump into this with you without chitter chatting right off the bat. Let's just let's just get right into it. first question is
Malin Lobb (00:28.408)
Let's do it.
gavin (00:30.697)
There was recently a really tragic accident in Spain where there was a low midair, both pilots died, and neither one threw a reserve and I was kinda surprised to get this question, you know, what what is too low to throw? And so why don't you take that one first? I was told by Jockey ages ago, I was doing some acro training with a buddy of his in Denis, this was fifteen years ago, and he said there there is no such thing as
Malin Lobb (00:49.528)
Mm-hmm.
gavin (01:00.521)
too low to throw, but hit me hit let's start there.
Malin Lobb (01:05.142)
Yeah, so the whole like, I think too low to throw is a very interesting thing to, like, I'm gonna circle back to that because ultimately that is the right advice. Because if you are in a cascade or you are lost, you won't understand the situation you're in. So just throw. As you gain a bit more experience, and the beauty of wind control is that,
you start to understand if I'm in this configuration I lose this amount of height. You will understand if you're in a left hand rotation or if you release the brakes you will go into a left hand rotation. In that instance I would say don't try and throw the reserve because the worst thing you can do if you've got, if you have to release your right brake to throw your reserve, if you have a left hand cravat and you release,
within a second and a half, in a 180 turn, you'll be in a nose down rotation. And if that's the moment of impact, you'll go from being in some sort of like parachute or stally configuration, maybe four to six meters a second descent, kind of like a fast reserve ride to nose down, which is quite often fatal. But that takes some situational awareness. That takes the situational awareness of like, I can't release this because that's there and it's trying to draw me in, therefore,
For me personally, I would rather stay with the wing and the drag above my head and go in than I would release it. If you're again at a certain level, but that takes quite a bit of understanding of your height loss and where you're at. If you're completely lost, then yeah, you might as well try it because it might not be a left-hand rotation you're going to go into. So it's a complicated question because, but the blanket thing of like, just get it out, you should do.
Once you've had a bit more training, you've got some big thing happen to you and you've got something stuck and you know you're going to go in anyway, if releasing it was going to mean a rotation, I wouldn't release it.
gavin (03:10.066)
Yeah, or a rotation or a restart, right? I mean, I think if the often like you said, if you're in a somewhat stable deep deep stall configuration, you've got some wing over your head and reaching for it allows it to boom and reset and and dig some error, you you could be in for a hard pound if you're really low. Yeah.
Malin Lobb (03:30.508)
Yeah, that's true. you know, if you're like twisted and it's stable in the stall, then releasing the brakes doesn't matter. So it's not going to matter then to throw. It might open, it might not. It's the rotations really, because especially if you've got a decent sized cravat, they wind in very quickly. Like it will go from above your head, two nose down, literally within a 180 degrees. And that could be the difference between a hard impact or a fatal impact really. So yeah.
gavin (03:37.139)
Yeah.
gavin (03:40.766)
Yep.
Malin Lobb (03:59.854)
Difficult question, but you know, there is this red zone where like, however good a pilot you are, if something happens within that red zone, you're going to impact. So it's minimizing that impact. And even if you're a really good pilot and with a bit more height, you could sort it out. You'll have that situation awareness. You'll know your height loss because you won't just have that tunnel vision. And you'll instantly know, I haven't got enough height for this. Like you do get an awareness of like, in what situation.
you lose x amount of height. yeah that's what I would say.
gavin (04:34.815)
That ties into a a good next one that came in that said I think folks should have an understanding of how much time it actually takes for a reserve to fully deploy. And so part of this question is what reserves do you like? What should you know, should we have a main reserve the that is a certain type? Should we have a secondary reserve that is a different type? but also this helps to understand terrain tolerance and the the the the
questioner here said I use a three and five second rule in my own flying five seconds to deal with an event plus an additional three to five seconds for the reserve to properly deploy. so yeah talk about that. Well I I'll continue with the question here. Both require all hands on deck, no screw ups, full focus, find altitude by thermaling or flying away from terrain under three sec seconds. I had
I have had a better place to land and and a thousand percent on my game. I get super weird under three second margin as that is super tight tolerance, conditions dependent of course. You know, so we're talking like I always think of Slovenia, you know, running that ri you know, you're s you're that run, you're always right on the terrain. You don't have much time. but yeah, how long does it take and how do you factor margin when you're thinking about reserve?
Malin Lobb (05:41.005)
Hmm.
Malin Lobb (05:49.685)
Yeah. I mean, in condition, yeah.
Malin Lobb (05:57.742)
Yeah so and if you tell me in what configuration you're in when you need to throw I'll tell you how long it's going to take because it's it's that if you're in a nose down thing with a little cravat but kind of a spirally feeling to it sorry it's got a cool then it's going to open very quickly and the likelihood of it going in your in your wing is much less if you're in a deep auto rotation sat like configuration
gavin (06:04.5)
Yeah.
Malin Lobb (06:25.577)
even if you throw towards the horizon, it's probably going to come down underneath you and then you're going to spiral and it will probably go in your wing. But your descent rate is much less. In a deep sated autorotation, you can be doing like four meters a second. So you could technically have someone on a kind of smaller reserve coming down like quicker than you, but you're doing like 60 kilometers an hour like that. So you still don't want to hit the ground, but your glancing angle is going to be much less.
So it all depends on the configuration. If you're twisted, but it's like in a stall, you might be doing four to six meters a second. So that kind of like three, five second rule really depends on the situation you're in. If I'm running ridges, like you say, like Slovenia, I tend to like to be like closer to the ridge than at a mid point where the reserve isn't going to open, but you've just increased your like potential energy. Maybe that's like a false sense of security, but it's a...
gavin (07:03.336)
Okay.
gavin (07:14.557)
Mm.
Malin Lobb (07:20.789)
if you have a, if you've a...
gavin (07:20.807)
In other words, ride closer to the ridge. You're not thinking reserve, you're thinking wing handling skills. Yeah.
Malin Lobb (07:27.359)
Yeah, because if you then go another 50 meters higher, you're still not going to get the reserve out, but you've increased your potential energy for impact, you know. And that might just be a false sense of like security of like, the ground is just there, so the impact's not going to be that hard. you know, it would be. But getting that extra bit of height for me doesn't have safety. Like you either need like quite a bit more height and then you're out of the race or you're out of the, you know, it's just not how we ride ridges.
gavin (07:56.501)
Mm.
Malin Lobb (07:56.622)
So yeah, but whatever happens height is your friend in paragliding height is your friend. That's the main rule if you wanna, we can compress this red zone I talked about before. Like I've been in comps before where you see someone at cloud base get frontal and they go into a rotation, they come out, still shoots, collapses, blah, blah. And you see them, blah, blah. And you think all reserves gonna come out and then they recover it, but they've lost like a thousand meters.
gavin (08:23.081)
Yeah. Yeah.
Malin Lobb (08:24.523)
So their red zone is a thousand meters. If they get a frontal at below that, they're going to have to throw their reserve. Whereas I've had a frontal at, you know, just above the tree height and you do the right input, it recovers and you fly away. like the better you get, the more you compress that zone. But with every flight, we're in that zone twice, takeoff and landing. And then if you fly in the Alps and you ridge run, you're in it the whole flight, you know? So you want to minimize, you want to compress that red zone as much as possible by getting your
gavin (08:39.957)
Mm.
Malin Lobb (08:53.899)
your actions and your prevention as good as possible. And then if you really want to be safe, you want to just try and stay out of it other than takeoff and landing.
gavin (09:04.421)
Mm. How how realistic is it? You know, we're taught that when we go to throw both brakes in one hand, keep low enough that it's somewhere, you know, backfly, deep stall, you don't have to be exact. You just want to keep the the the wing overhead, and then throw. In in reality and what you're seeing in SIV, are people doing that?
Malin Lobb (09:26.785)
I think, you know, if...
gavin (09:27.185)
Is that realistic to expect people to do it?
Malin Lobb (09:30.412)
I think just getting it out as quick as possible is the thing. Like I don't believe in the, if you're in this rotation, throw at your feet, or if you're in that rotation, throw this way or that way. If you are in a position where you have to throw, you've lost your situational awareness. You don't know if you're rotating left or right or up or down. So don't overthink it. Just try and get that out into clean air as quick as possible. And then as for grabbing the other break, like with these small aggressive acro wings, if you...
and whether that's come from the acro world or not, but if you just release the brakes, it can be like super stalled to infinite time, whereas on your recreational glider, it's not gonna have that much energy, but it's gonna stop it instantly winding into a rotation, so maybe it's not a bad idea. It depends how much time you waste thinking about grabbing the brake to then go for the reserve, like whether that payoff is worth it or not. So just getting something out into clean air because
depending on the rotation you're in, it's more than likely going to go into your wing anyway. know, the amount of stuff you've seen online, the amount of stuff I've seen over the years, where if you're in that satid auto rotation, quite often it will either hit the wing and then grab some air and inflate, or it will get tangled in the wings. There's also a possibility. So just get it out. But then what's really important once you've thrown is you watch it.
gavin (10:45.055)
Take it on the way.
Malin Lobb (10:51.767)
So watch it go, the bridle's gonna rip up around if you've got a shoulder, which most of them are, the shoulder connections. So you're watching it go so you can see if there's a problem or you see it starting to inflate and you can grab the bridle as it comes up around as well. So if it hasn't fully inflated, then you can get the bridle and start to give it some inputs.
gavin (11:13.365)
And so would you say w you know, watching and giving some inputs 'cause that's the next part of the question is direction to throw a reserve during an incident like auto rotation. You know, if you're if you're auto rotating to the left, is it more y what I'm hearing from you is don't worry about that, throw it and watch it.
Malin Lobb (11:32.078)
Yeah, you won't know which way you're turning. And the thing is, you do, if you have the situational awareness for what's going on, then you would get out of the situation. You wouldn't have lost control because you will understand what's going on and you'll be able to do something about it. It's when you feel like you're out of control, in which case you're gonna have that tunnel vision, you're gonna be so stressed and there's no point in giving it those seconds or milliseconds to try and figure out which way you're going.
gavin (11:34.973)
Okay.
gavin (11:40.754)
Hm.
Malin Lobb (11:59.598)
What's important is you look at the reserve handle rather than trying to feel it. Matt Wilkster did great detailed studies on this. So just look at the reserve handle, pull and throw in one motion. You will use your bicep as you start to pull it, but then just let it go. And just get it out there so it starts to come out of the bag and it starts to get some air into it. The advice of throw towards your feet or throw the other way.
kind of in that situation when you look at how humans behave under stress that will all go.
gavin (12:35.89)
Okay. we talked about this with Chris Holeb a little bit, who teaches SIV and did really good acropilot. And he had some conflict with this this concept of using stall as a reset. What's your opinion on that?
Malin Lobb (12:53.759)
I think that stall as a reset is it means that you're missing some pilot action or situational awareness. So if you're in a cascade that needs resetting, there's quite a simple way of never being in that cascade event. So if you have a clean catch and release, you should never get yourself into a cascade like that. So if you're having a glide that dives front tools,
reloads, stalls because you've got some brake on, then you're not catching because you're not aware that it's diving or you're not using enough brakes so it collapses again, restalls. But a clean catch and release sorts that out. So you can learn that from rapid exits, from natural exits, for all those sort of things. it's diving hard you use the full brake range, if it's not you don't. But the second that it's stopped you release, you'll never get yourself into a cascade that you need to stall out of basically.
So if you are completely lost and you are one of those pilots, then for sure that is a reset option, but actually with just quite a little bit of training and then something that you can take from that training and go and practice yourself, getting a clean catch and release, not being afraid to use the last part of the break range should mean that you then don't need it. Like becoming good makes the situations where you need a stool less and less and less.
to the point where other than acro training, I can't remember the last time I did a stall in the wild, like in anger, because I've now got, even with frontals on comp wings, just a big input to open the center, I would rather let it shoot. I would rather like do an input and see, you know, the center open, even if the rest isn't, I'd rather let that shoot and then clean it with a big catch as it shoots hard than I would stall it and, you know.
gavin (14:30.976)
Grab it. Release.
Malin Lobb (14:47.181)
try and clean it on the exit.
gavin (14:50.26)
Are there any wing s are there any XC slash wing scenarios, certain types of cravats or anything that would call for a stall?
Malin Lobb (14:59.777)
Yeah. And then, so that's the other thing about you're probably missing a skill is that when you get good at defensively flying, so you feel a collapse coming, you see it and you're using the full break range. So you're not just trying to refine pressure, but you're trying to go deeper than pressure to like really change the angle of attack. Even if you're having like an 80 % monster, you'll reduce that to like 40 % or something. So even if you end up with a cravat, it will be small enough that you can spin it out.
If you're getting cravats which are half the wing, you've basically got no brake pressure. Like everything is soft on that one side, but that kind of proves to me that you haven't been defensive enough. So again, when you learn to be more aggressive on the brakes, when you learn to like being really be smacking collapses, punching collapses, it means that you don't have half your wing in a cravat. If you do, say you're like playing with your instruments or getting some food or something like that, and you end up with half cravat, you have to stall it.
you can't spin that side because there's no, literally no brakes, no pressure, in which case you do have to stall out of it. But it's a very different stall. It's not that kind of like straight drop rack. You have to, with this slack hand, go to the tail slide position and then as you pull this one, which it will stall very high and very easy, you just then match it on the other side and you get this like 90 degree turn as you drop into it. And that will be effective. But other than that, like I would always choose to spin a...
that out rather than stall it unless I was in that situation.
gavin (16:33.078)
spin versus fishing, you know, you've you've got so all the lines soft. Are you putting it in your teeth and pulling until you get something? what w where where do you decide where to go in that scenario?
Malin Lobb (16:38.199)
Hmm.
Malin Lobb (16:48.951)
So what I teach there is that, like the process of a cravat is you've got a cravat. So the first thing is ignore it because people just get obsessed by it. So it's stop the rotation because it will try and rotate you and it's constant. It's constant drag. So it's constantly trying to pull you in, which is different to a collapse, which starts to come out and the amount of break you need then starts to like lessen off. It's constant. So stop the rotation, get a new heading.
and get some clearance from terrain. And then the last thing before you try and clear it is look at the type of cravat you have. So if you have the classic cravat which is like laying on the front of the lines, a spin will work really well because it's being held there by the forward pressure and then you blow it off from behind. Basically when you start to spin it, the air is coming from a different direction. If you have it like between the lines, it doesn't matter if it's flying forwards or backwards, it's not gonna matter.
you have a line over or if you have one that's like right on the tip and like a little knotted thing then the spin is probably not the best thing. So just before you try and clear it, because there are several methods, is check what type of cravat you've ended up with and then decide. So if it's laying on front which is the majority of cravats I would try and spin it and there's a couple of techniques we can we can talk about. If it's through or there's a line I think I like
Back in the Ice Peak 8 days, I had a cravat which came out and it was like a spider web of knots in my line and I punched it and I just broke all my upper brake cascade. So unloading and reloading works. On a two-liner, can pull a big ear and a knot, but on three-liners, it's easier to pull a collapse and then recover and then little pump, collapse. Just unload and reload, knots kind of works.
If it's a little knot at the tip, the stabila line works, kind of teasing your hand up and then kind of pulling can work. And then if you're low and you don't have time to sort it, don't be too obsessed with it. Don't be too obsessed with turning into wind as well. Like we can land downwind, it doesn't look pretty, but lift your legs up and just skid in. Because turning with a cravat, you always want to turn towards the cravat.
Malin Lobb (19:04.663)
So if you are high enough to set up for a final approach, let the cravat do the work. So like, let it pull you towards the cravat and then stop it, let it pull you towards, never try and fight it because you'll be at, yeah, you'll spin it so much easier and you'll be at just at the point where you don't want to spin it. And then gauging on whether you should just throw or not would be some cravats you have, you really feel like even with full weight shift that.
gavin (19:16.486)
Mm.
gavin (19:23.03)
Mm.
Malin Lobb (19:31.405)
you're near the stall point on that side of the wing. It feels like a little bit banana-y. It feels like a little bit like, it's right there. I wouldn't go near the ground like that because you always get a bit of ground turbulence at kind of 10 meters, like right when you wouldn't want the wing to stall. So yeah, if I was like, I can't go near the ground like that and I've tried and it's not coming out, then I would throw in that scenario. Now I've never been in that situation. When I first started flying comp wings, cravats used to be a bit of an ordeal.
gavin (19:46.336)
So just throw in those scenarios. Yeah.
Malin Lobb (20:00.748)
because I'd get one and it would go into a bit of rotation. I'd stop it, I'd try and clear it and it would get a little bit smaller, but then, you know, I'd lose X amount of height and be sweating by the end of it. And now I'm much more aggressive with my initial input. So if I'm getting a collapse, my hand is like down as deep as it will go. And it starts to collapse, especially on the higher aspect ratio wings, where it might be touching the lines. kind of goes, bing, bing, bing, bing. It kind of like bounces off it as it starts to spin.
So like they just don't register in the first place. Even if you're a little bit late catching it, you're punching the collapse and you're spinning in one motion rather than like punching and that didn't work. And then having to do the cravat clearing, you kind of combine the two to your punched it, but you're just waiting for it to work. And then.
gavin (20:48.277)
You just had a really good art go ahead.
Malin Lobb (20:51.15)
Yeah, well, yeah, no, you go and then I'll talk about the, my preferred method of clearing now because I've made it little more detailed.
gavin (20:58.709)
No, go ahead, do that, 'cause you're you're on a roll. Go ahead.
Malin Lobb (21:01.88)
So like three or four years ago I mentioned this movement that for clearing cravats more like easier basically because I noticed that if you add a roll movement to cravat clearing it becomes easier. So what you need to really make sure if you're going to spin a cravat out first of all if you spin the side where the cravat is because we did have a question about that. So on the cravatted side once you have
Stop the rotation, got a new heading, got some clearance, had a breath, checked what method you're use. Then you spin it. You have to punch and hold and it has to be as deep and as quick as possible because if you do it gradually, you will initiate a turn. So if you're gonna be completely straight and level, then you have to make sure you're down there as quick as possible. But you have to make sure you are completely straight. If you're in a slight turn,
As you add more drag on this side, it will quite happily go into a steeper turn and you cannot clear a cravat in a rotation because if you do end up spinning it and you've gathered some centrifugal force, it will be like a McTwist. So you really don't want to do that. And if it doesn't, it will just go into a deep spiral and you're losing a lot of height. Now, if you set up adverse roll, then the wing will spin easier because it's impossible for a wing to be rolling this way, but turn that way.
gavin (22:09.985)
Mm. Mm.
Malin Lobb (22:25.442)
So it's setting yourself up so that when the glider starts to roll, you do your input. You don't get a normal flying straight spin. You get a 90 degree turn and then a shoot and you've cleared the cravat. With this adverse roll movement that I've come up with, you don't get the same 90 degree turn. You don't get the same dive because you're basically set for your...
gavin (22:48.863)
Say say what you're saying now and imagine people can't see you. I will put this out on YouTube for everybody listening. Usually these are just audio podcasts. This will be a video version of this. So if you're listening and you don't understand what Malin's saying, then I'll this there will be a video version, but try this'll this will be this'll be tricky. But say say that th and you're talking to an audience, they can't see you, yeah.
Malin Lobb (23:06.062)
testing me. Okay so most, well there is this old thing, this old thing of like if you, like a stool is a great way of clearing cravats and then actually when you start to learn stools you realise it's actually the best way of getting cravats. So imagine a stool exit where one side is cravatted, we'll say it's the right hand side. As your body is pendulming through, normally, and this is the first step,
is you would weight shift left, you'd use left brake, and that would mean that as you pendulum through, you're flying straight. Then we chill out, we look at the cravat, we spin it and clear it. The next step to that, once you've got good situational awareness, is you have, the glider's dived, it's got a cravat on the right-hand side. So as your body starts to pendulum through and recover from the stall, it's gonna pull you to the right. So you're gonna start this right-hand turn, and you allow it to take you.
little bit. You allow it to roll you to the right before using left brake and left weight shift and then you leave that on and as you then pendulum through, we call that the exit window, the bottom of the pendulum, it's going to start the roll to the left. So you are going to have just started, you're going to be at the vertical under the glider, it's going to start rolling you to the left and that is when you do your input. So you're fighting roll as you do your input.
the glider is now just slightly behind you. So you've set it up with two things. One, adverse roll, so the glider will spin easier, and two, the wing slightly behind you as it's losing energy. And you'll find that there's less brake pressure and the wing will spin easier. So you don't need to leave your hand down as long, because it's not like a positively flying wing that's like departing from flight after a while. It's already in that fragile position where it's like, straight away it wants to spin.
gavin (24:38.103)
Mm.
Malin Lobb (24:56.662)
And Gavin, know, if you do a bit of training, you'll know when you've got it right because like your usual like spin to like come on spin and then it goes. You'll set it up for this like beautiful moment where you just go, and it just comes out and there's like less pressure and it goes easier.
gavin (25:04.993)
Yeah.
gavin (25:11.209)
And you're kinda going against the possibility of like you said, initiating a turn that ends up kind of in a down spiral or something. You're you're you're you're you're working against that. So that makes a lot of sense. I like that.
Malin Lobb (25:18.67)
Exactly.
Yeah, so the danger with that movement is that you get it too late. So the roll has then come to a stop and it's just about to roll back and that's when you do your input because that will exaggerate that movement. So you've got to do it just as it starts to roll back, just as you pass under that. And that's why it's not like something I'd say do this from the start. Yeah, it will because it yeah, exactly. So that's why I'm like this is like a more advanced technique. You've got to get used to doing stools coming out of a cravat.
gavin (25:40.407)
Where it kinda has more energy. Where it has kinda the most energy. Yeah. Mm-hmm.
Malin Lobb (25:52.163)
flying it straight, clearing it. Then we start to play with like, okay, allow it to take you a little bit, then stop it, leave that brake on, allow the roll to just start and clean it. And it's super effective.
gavin (26:05.185)
This is a good segue. You just had a really good article about brake use in XC Mag, and I thought maybe this would th this warranted an audio version of that. Can you summarize that article and and you know what you've learned in all these years of teaching SIV and that most pilots don't use the full range of their brakes and why that's dangerous?
Malin Lobb (26:30.132)
Yeah, I can't actually remember the article because it must have, I don't know if it's an old one that's been redone or like, yeah yeah. But it's true, I mean it's one of the fundamentals, the full brake range, and it's not a physical thing because we can all have our hands above our head and put them down past our hips. I see the last part of that brake range is a real psychological thing because, well especially when we first start flying, we're never used the deeper part of the brake range.
gavin (26:33.271)
I know, we write these six months beforehand.
Malin Lobb (26:58.658)
But also the feeling you get is the brake pressure increases and increases and increases. And you get to a certain point where that pressure then drops off and that can feel quite disconcerting. So it's about getting used to putting yourself in a situation. Again, this is why I use the rapid exit a lot because we get that then that situation where, okay, we can use that full brake range safely.
and it's getting used to that disconcerting feeling of like, that pressure's suddenly gone and the wing is distorting and I can see the pressure leaving the glider, but then it's like super effective. And there are certain dives that you really need it. And there's certain situations like the cravat clearing where you really need it. And it shouldn't take any more cognition to use the last part of the break range or the first part of the break range. That first like 15, 20 centimeters and the last.
15, 20 centimeters, there should be no more fear, no more apprehension. It's like when you're parking your car, if you're using the full steering lock, you don't go like, bloody hell, I'm like, really, yeah. You just need what you need, and it should be like that in paragliding. If you need that last bit, you're in a situation where you better use it.
gavin (28:05.74)
I'm at the edge. Yeah.
gavin (28:22.616)
Great. Josh Cone, our good friend, asked a good one, I'd be interested to hear a discussion about the order of operations for a low collapse, e.g., go for reserve instantly, give the glider a chance to recover, etcetera. Is there a height below which it's better to hold the glider installed than go for reserve? So we kinda we we open with that, but let's go back to our maybe our Slovenia Ridge Roar ridge running example. There was actually a f a follow-up to that from
our good buddy Doug Annawalt who went in pretty hard down at the World Cup in in Brazil in this exact scenario. It was I'm really low. I think I should ride this in under deep stall. you know, he pounded pretty hard, but and he felt like the harness, you know, he got lucky, as we often do with mistakes, luckily, but yeah, just b explore that a little bit.
Malin Lobb (29:18.678)
Yeah, I think we kind of mostly covered it, but you know, but that's where, know, when you start to race ridges, it's like, you need to keep that wing open. You know, you have to really be on it on the bees, on the brakes, whatever you're on, don't let it collapse. And then if it does, it depends on the type of collapse. And then the more training you do, you know, even front tools and again, like I say, even on comp wings, like these...
the wings that have got a lot of plastic in now, which is even like photons and all the ENCs, when they frontal, they're a bit different to normal wings with higher cord, like that tend to like crumple up. They tend to like fly down a bit more as a block. And then you can really like, as they start to kind of like fly down towards you, you can really like pull them back and open them back out. It's not like a collapse where it does that. They kind of like, they start to unload and you can, you know, like I've seen up into the
gavin (29:59.448)
Okay.
gavin (30:07.96)
Yeah.
Malin Lobb (30:13.858)
the nose of the internals before, because the wing is starting to invert itself and you can bring it back from that. yeah, people on two-liners, they don't use the full range of the bees. So I do a lot of training with that. when people turn up on, because ENC two-liners are now all the rage, and people turn up with not a lot of sieve experience, so we can't do the collapse to rotation and all that sort of stuff. But there's a lot I work on with how to use the bees and
the range you've got and where the spin point is and spinning on the bees is actually really nice because it's more gentle than on the brakes. So we spend time on getting like to the spin point gently or getting deeper than the spin point and coming to it and just allowing it to turn going to full speed on the bees. Yeah. And the difference is like, if this is your like spin point is maybe like, I don't know.
gavin (30:59.456)
On the bees. Yeah.
Malin Lobb (31:09.198)
let's say 10 centimeters lower, well when you're at full speed you're not at the trim speed, you're all the way up here, so then you've got all that range down to there, but it's only the spin point if you stay there. And just like the brakes, if you're having a frontal you can go past the the stall point and release and it doesn't stall, and it's the same thing with like, okay I know what this spin feeling is, so if I'm like really riding...
If I'm going through turbulence and I'm really riding it, I know what that soft feeling is and I can release and then get back on. if I'm getting in front of it, I can go deeper than that as long as I'm back up. Another thing with the Bs is once you start to spin it, it's very easy to have some pressure. You'll know from full bar if you really want true full speed on the Enzo's. I don't know what too much the Nivet ones are, but if you just rest your hands and you're at full speed, it's not the same as pushing up slightly.
gavin (31:59.615)
Mm-hmm. Same. It's the same on the X one.
Malin Lobb (31:59.661)
you get an extra like little, yeah, so you get a little bit of extra speed and when you're recovering from a spin or something negative on the bees, you think your hands are up. So you actually need to like push until you feel the webbing go tight to recover on the bees. So, which is different to the brakes, because the brakes have got that kind of like, you know, that bit of slack built into them and you can get away with it. Like the glider will recover even with a little bit of pressure on, but the bees, you really need to like physically push to get a clean recovery.
gavin (32:14.946)
Mm.
Malin Lobb (32:29.518)
So yeah, I think if you're riding ridges and stuff, you want to be on it with the bees, you want to know what's going on. And then, yeah, we talked before about, yeah, and then we talked before, like, if there's any sort of, like, left-hand rotation, I wouldn't allow it to ramp up, to throw. yeah, well, you know, if it's rotating to the right, you've got the left break, you can keep the left break in your hand, and you can release this one and throw.
gavin (32:36.876)
What the Wang's saying.
gavin (32:46.134)
Yeah. Rotation either way. Yeah.
Malin Lobb (32:56.632)
So like if you understand which side is the crevated, then you can be like, well it's crevated on the right and I need to release the right brake, so that's fine, because I'm not doing anything with that hand, because you know, I'm gonna go in. So you can stay on that. Now, you could put this hand in there, but with a crevat, it either wants to like draw you into rotation, or you're in this like stall, refly rotation, stall, refly rotation state. And once you get good, but.
actually really quite good at wind control. You can stay in that like, and this is more, it used to be more END and above wings that had this characteristic, but now I'm seeing it like in, even in the B category where you have a cravat and it starts to want to go into rotation and you stop the rotation, it will stall instantly, even from quite far in front. It used to be the ENDs would like be quite far into the rotation and then they'd start to stall and ENDs would come all the way back.
to the exit window and then stall on the reload. after a while, you can play this little game of the glider flies. You pull it, and just as about to stall, you release it. And then you're playing in that kind of parachute or refly, parachute or refly phase. And that in itself can clear the cravat. Every time it just goes chup and doesn't fly and then reflies and then chup doesn't fly and reflies, it's getting the cravat smaller. And if you put your other hand
gavin (34:20.682)
Interesting. I never heard of that.
Malin Lobb (34:22.817)
Yeah, so there was a video that kind of went a bit viral a few years ago, quite a years ago now with, I was debriefing one of the Race Academy guys, he had a bit of a cravat cascade thing and it just got shared. was like a WhatsApp video that went, did the rounds and I was explaining that scenario. So if you ever get to that point in your wing control where you can play with that, you're not...
to be able to like pass the break to that side and have that same finesse to then throw and what happens is then if it stalls and you don't release slightly to let it try and recover is it will stall like more violently and then it will recover more violently and you get much bigger back pitch shoots try to rotate then because there's a bit more centrifugal force it stalls and if you and if you hit the ground in that configuration then you can hurt yourself so
why I'd rather have that finesse of that like slight reflying stalling and go in than either a full rotation or rotation to dynamic stall to rotation to dynamic stall.
gavin (35:17.88)
Mm.
gavin (35:30.282)
And is this actually something you're practicing in your your S I V courses? I mean, how how are you having somebody initiate a cravat to do this?
Malin Lobb (35:40.654)
Yes, I'm not. I think this is when my, like the reserve rides on my course went down was when I really looked at like, okay, we do like an S I V, auto rotation, and then we do some more training and then someone would get a cravat and it would lead to a reserve ride. And I would see other schools like why were reserve rides happening? And it was always cravat to auto rotation to reserve. And I realized that actually, you know, from my own training and then
mucking around is that how you exit an alteration in a real life is very different to the SIV configuration. So when you pull a collapse, it's kind of like a streamer, like there's not much drag to it. So even like weight shift, sometimes you can come out. So you're holding the collapse and then it doesn't take much break either. Like you'll find that from like a spiral, if you switch hands, you have no drag on that side.
so it's easy to come out, comes out nice and dynamically. Then you pull a collapse and you have a little bit of drag on that side, so you might find a little bit more force, but it will still come out fairly easy. Now with a cravat, it's much higher brake pressure, much higher, and you have to pull more, and then it will stall on the exit. So when you see someone come out of a cravatid autorotation and it stalls on the exit, you think, well, they've pulled too much brake, but they haven't, it's just that...
If you have X amount of drag on this side and you have to put more drag on the other side to come out, the wing is just gonna stall because as you reload the glider, you're increasing that wing loading. It can't possibly fly. So you get this little stall exit. Now, when I say it's harder pressure as well, I have a couple of good videos of students using two hands on the exit brake. it was like back in the day before I'd really like refined my.
gavin (37:23.501)
Mm.
Malin Lobb (37:36.019)
methods it was like I'd be getting people out of the and I'd say like it's higher pressure and they're like it wasn't physical enough to pull it and then I would see in the videos that like they were either pulling into their body a bit like if you've ever tried to do a sat and you know you get to a certain point with a sat you're like fuck I can't pull anymore they would get to that with the autorotation and it's like well we need to then like change how you're you know how you're pulling or okay you can like get better mechanical advantage in a different way but it's mentally preparing people that
gavin (37:48.513)
Yeah.
Yeah.
Malin Lobb (38:04.34)
in a real life scenario with a cravat you will have higher pressure than you've ever felt before and you will have to pull that brake harder than you've ever pulled it before and that's if it's ramped in past like 45 degrees so if if you're starting to tighten a turn and it's not like that fast yet it doesn't take as much if it ramps in to something deeper you might need two hands on it because you literally might not be physical enough so it's just getting it's preparing people for it
gavin (38:13.646)
Mm.
Malin Lobb (38:32.364)
And that's why, like how it used to be taught of like, just weight shift out, you'll come out fine. It's like not in a real life situation, you won't. And just pulling a little bit of break, like whatever you've practiced in SIV for coming out of auto rotation, when you're in a real life, cravatted one, will be different. So you will have to pull harder than you've ever had to pull. And then you will get this stall exit. So you need to be ready as you pass under the bottom of the apex through the exit window, you have to get ready to release the brake.
gavin (38:32.536)
Mm.
gavin (38:48.663)
Yeah, sure.
Malin Lobb (39:00.782)
So again, it's, and when I saw that I put that extra detail and I got the right videos and I prepped people, it meant that my reserve rides went down from my students a lot because they were ready for it. They started to wind in and they weren't like, I this brake and that normally works. Well, that's not working. It's like, shit, I know that I need to get on it. And...
gavin (39:28.013)
Mm.
Malin Lobb (39:29.142)
And now like in the last three years, think I've had, so I've had two reserves in last three years, which is like four and a half, nearly four and a half thousand SIV flights. With the amount of SIV I do, I think it's like 4,400 SIV flights and two reserves. like my, yeah, so like the methods that they're working and it's not that people are getting themselves, they are getting themselves into trouble a little bit less because I've like refined how I like, yeah, refined stuff as well.
gavin (39:34.531)
Jeez Wow
gavin (39:45.185)
It's unbelievable.
gavin (39:55.235)
Find it.
Malin Lobb (39:58.659)
but they're still getting into trouble, but then they've got the tools and I've pre-warned them about how to get out of it, which is kind of the point of Like really the real Civ starts when they cock something up and they are a little bit out of control. It's like, if they can get out of that, that's much more like a real life situation. If in that situation where it's gone a bit wrong, they're throwing their reserve straight away. It's like, well, the training hasn't worked.
gavin (40:05.985)
Yeah. Yeah.
gavin (40:21.731)
Hm. Mm. Well, it's worked in a sense. They're throwing. That's good. Better than not.
Malin Lobb (40:25.346)
That's true, yeah. And you learn a lot, you you really learn a lot from it. Other than like a midair I had in a World Cup once, like I've not thrown an anger, but I've done a lot of testing, like every reserve we throw, like back in the day, I used to like test. And then when I had that midair and I had to throw, even though I'd done it over the lake and in like test configurations and I would test like, okay, how much does it downplay? Like if I leave it in a half flying state, what's the...
pendulum instability, then I'd use quick outs to come down like properly. I was doing it as a test, but when I got there and in that real life situation and I threw it just felt so natural, like because even in that test like environment, it was like, I've done that before. So it's definitely, it's definitely worth doing.
gavin (41:13.869)
to the reserves themselves, I I I didn't let you totally finish that one. The question was, you know, is i does it change at all the time it takes to open depending on the reserves. So, you know, beamer versus square, square steerable, round, do you have a favorite? Is there is there a way we should you know, for th for people flying with two reserves, should should one type be on one side, one type be on another side?
Malin Lobb (41:26.99)
Hmm.
Malin Lobb (41:38.349)
Yeah, yeah so I, so obviously in comps we fly with two, with acro we fly with two, so in acro I, on my like dominant hand, I fly with the regalo because acro is actually far safer than in cross-country which surprises a lot of people, but we're in this confined environment and as long as you don't break the rule of not doing acro low we always have height, so I want a steerable on my
quick draw hand. Whereas in cross country it's the opposite. want, you know, if I'm low and boom I get a blowout or I see a twist and I just want to throw, I don't want a steerable. Because I'm low I'm not going to be able to use it and it might have some sort of forward speed and it will probably open the way I don't want it to open. It will just add complexity to it. But now if I'm high at cloud base and I have a mid-air and I've got a second to be like okay this is happening
then I can choose to use the steerable because I've got the height to then use its features.
gavin (42:43.097)
Hmm. So you'll put your steer on your XC kit, you'll put your steerable in your non-dominant hand. Hmm. Fascinating.
Malin Lobb (42:48.608)
yeah because it means I've got height and I've got time to think about which one I'm gonna I'm gonna use because steerables they so there's something called the charlie diamond cross or the the cortile crisis cave it's the same the same one but it's basically like a square which is turned like a diamond shape above your head it's got like four dyneema risers coming off it and just some loops for handles it's like really quite simple compared to a regalo so if you do want if you just have one and you do want that option
I'd probably go for that one because if you throw and it's like, you know, twisted up and you're just like, it'll open and you land, it's less complicated than a Gallo, which can sometimes come out with line overs. It opens with a 90 degree turn. So you've always got this like, it's crossed behind the back of your head. It's got brake lines. So you have to pull the brakes off. Like for, for, for Acro where you've got height, the wings are easier to stall. You might have quick outs.
you've got the luxury of height, it's great, know, you're in the box, boom, you see it all the time in Turkey where they then fly and they do a beach landing. That's brilliant. But with cross-country flying, once you become a good pilot, it's the low, big events that you'll want to throw. If you've got the luxury of height and you're not wrapped up with someone else, you've got the skill to sort it out.
gavin (44:10.126)
Yeah. Yep.
Malin Lobb (44:10.382)
that makes sense, like you just become a good enough pilot they're like okay a bit of free SRV here I've got the height and something's happening but I know how to get out of it. It's the low big blowouts you want to throw and in that instant I don't want a steerable I want something that's going to go boom and then boom land. So we always recommend being like 20 percent, at least 20 percent under the maximum weight range. If you're near the top of the weight range it's the opposite of wings like you get your worst performance.
And if you're coming down at 5.5 meters a second, that's like jumping off a wall that's like a meter and a half high. But actually we always fly in wind, so it's like sprinting off a wall that high. And then if you've got like boulders laid out in front of you, like ankle breakers, it's like jumping into them. But then with your wing, unless you've got rid of your wing, you're coming down backwards because the wing has some drag. So if you're happy to jump off a wall that's a meter and a half high into uneven terrain, running and then
gavin (44:38.756)
Yeah.
Malin Lobb (45:07.65)
turning backwards. So 5.5 isn't ideal. And then we always fly in turbulence. So I had a student that lives in Chamonix who did all the right things. He oversized his reserve, he had a square. So I wouldn't recommend you buy a round. think rounds should be discontinued from our sport. And he had a new wing, like three months old, and it had a collapse and shock-reinflated, and he broke the center A's.
gavin (45:11.649)
Yeah.
gavin (45:27.034)
Okay.
Malin Lobb (45:37.113)
and he was at like 3000 meters in the Chamonix Valley. So he took it to tail slide and he basically tail slid down to like a suitable height because he didn't want to like land on a glacier or, you know, and he threw and he landed on a screed slope, but he still landed hard enough that he had to get the air ambulance because he thought he'd broken his back. So if he'd been on a smaller one or a round one where he'd pendulanded, he really could have caused himself harm. And that's because you might be landing in descending air. You know, if you're in a mountain terrain,
you're probably going to be in the Valley of Doom when you throw low, you know, there's boulders, there's trees, there's all sorts. Like you want to be coming down gently. And if you're in like four meters a second descending air and you add that to the five and a half meters a second, it's like jumping out of a second story window onto uneven terrain. So going bigger is better to a certain point. And like Russ, yeah.
gavin (46:11.79)
Nasty.
gavin (46:27.0)
Hm. Mm. How about how b how about for for single reserves, you know, so your hike and fly kit type stuff, XALPS, what what what what would be your if you only had one, what's your choice?
Malin Lobb (46:41.454)
Yeah, so actually I, when I was into Volbiv, I would have a spreadsheet with like all of the grams. Yeah, and I would like cut my toothbrush in half. Yeah, all that sort of stuff, you know, and I was, but then my reserve, it was like 200 grams more for like a 120 rather than 100, even though I could fly at like 85, 90 with all of my kit. But, and again, because it's like,
gavin (46:54.596)
Toothbrush and half, yeah, yeah.
gavin (47:07.832)
Mm.
Malin Lobb (47:10.902)
It's annoying because like for me reserves is just a really expensive hobby. I've never got them out. I don't use them, but I buy them and I put them away. then, so it's like, it's a very expensive hobby for not using the thing. but it's like cross-country races, vol biv, they're the sort of things where if you do throw, you're probably going to be above a spiky mountain or in the valley of doom somewhere. And it's like, that's probably where you really, those 200 extra grams like
really probably not that much of a problem and it's so tempting to, especially when you get good, to just be like, well I never use it anyway so I'm just going to get the smallest lightest thing possible. the more, like now I've kind of maybe grown up a bit or seen enough accidents that I do a lot of hike and fly and I used to fly like the the lightest weight single skins with like a strap harness, sometimes no helmet, never a reserve.
And then I see like people crashing and it's never the accident you think you're going to have. It's always the stupid little things like you get a twig caught in a line, but you've taken off or, you you might be filming someone and you crash into someone else or like you have something like it's, it's never the thing you think that's going to happen. So now like a kit's got lighter anyway, but now I fly with like a double sky, fly like an ultra light. I've got the, an inflatable back protector. I've got a lightweight reserve. and I've
like at least psychologically I feel better. But for sure, if I get myself into the situation where, you know, I did get a collapse, which knotted and wouldn't come out, I wouldn't just be spiraling down with nothing. I think, you know, the more kind of random stuff you see in the sport, the more you start to like perceive risks slightly differently anyway. But for sure, if you're ever coming down on a reserve, you are descending at the height you're descending, know, the speed you're descending at, and there's nothing you can do about it. So.
Oversize it a bit, it's worth it.
gavin (49:06.052)
So not so much important other than not round and bigger. Those are the two w we wanna go with there. It can be beamer, it can be square, it can be steerable, non steerable, but not round and go bigger and size up.
Malin Lobb (49:13.046)
yeah for me like
Malin Lobb (49:20.086)
Yeah, because the thing with rounds is they're pendulum unstable. So if you overside them, if you oversized them, they get more pendulum unstable. Whereas squares have solved that problem. You can oversize them without increasing that pendulum instability. And the thing when you're in like medicine or tech or anything like that, when something better comes out, the old stuff usually like disappears. Whereas for some reason in our sport, know, squares have come out, they solve all the problems that round have, but you can still buy a round. I don't understand it. So.
gavin (49:23.396)
Yeah.
gavin (49:34.734)
Gotcha.
gavin (49:49.944)
Yeah, yeah.
Malin Lobb (49:50.498)
just stop buying them guys and then the manufacturers will stop making them.
gavin (49:54.351)
They'll stop making them. Yeah, good point. this is a good one. it's kinda interesting. Obviously opinion matters here, but obviously for you in a perfect world you get all the SIV bookings you can, but we know there are a lot of options. What are some good questions for beginner pilots or any pilot for that matter to ask when looking for an SIV instructor? How does how to decipher the good ones from the basic ones from the clickbait ones?
Malin Lobb (50:21.166)
Hmm, yeah. This is so difficult. Yeah, I don't know. For me, yeah, I'm a bit like disillusioned by the whole SIV game at the moment because there is such a variety of skill out there with SIV instructing. My ultimate game in life is to have some, have some, like,
our industry needs some sort of regulation because SIV is becoming more popular, which means everyone is just jumping on the bandwagon. And the difference between bad instruction, which can potentially kill you, or even just a bad setup and a good one, there's a massive disparity. And it is very hard for someone to know because even like a goodish one still...
I've heard some stuff out there which is just basic. It's such a shame that I get sent videos and I see stuff online and someone will do a maneuver and then I hear, yeah, that was great, it was good. it's like, could have mentioned 10 little things to make that better. And then there's some just dangerous stuff where people like impact the water and then you see that the boat's not even in the water, it's still on the beach and they're trying to put the boat in. So there is no regulation which...
there needs to be something. And I've created these like pilot proficiency levels and I've done most of the work to kind of get this done. So if anyone's listening and you are part of a federation or you know who to speak to to get this moving, then I'm more than happy to help out because ultimately that's what we need. And really you can't tell because, I mean, I would try and get hold of the instructor and just ask a load of questions and get feedback, but
You know, the sort of stuff I did with, so there's a video, it was when I was with Flyo, so it's on the Flyo YouTube about testing life jacket sizes, rescue procedures. There should be a standard in like at least a 270 Newton life jacket that the person on the boat is first aid qualified, that you have some sort of rescue board, because having a rescue boat, you're like, sweet, I'm safe. But if it's a high sided one,
Malin Lobb (52:43.509)
you're not going to get an unconscious or non-breathing person over that. It's like physically impossible to lift an 80 kilo dead weight over the side of a boat. So you need a rescue procedure. You need to have tested it and tried it out. And that's even before we get to talking about is the instructor good or not. It should be like there is a bare minimum like standard. There's people out there still not teaching with video debriefs.
you know, and the amount of science out there about that whole do and review, it's like you're going to learn so much less than if you have that review process afterwards. So I don't know, it's, it's, it's the, are living through the wild west of, of SIV at the moment. And it's a real shame because
gavin (53:30.204)
What's frustrating is I think we have been for an awfully long time. I mean you could say everything you just said and replace SIV with guiding. I mean it it's like life coaching. People need no training whatsoever to be a life coach. They just call themselves a life coach and that's what's happening with guiding. I mean p everybody's guiding these days. And you know, guiding's different if you know an area, great, you can take people in there, but you know, there's no there's no demand or there's no regulation whatsoever.
Malin Lobb (53:48.94)
Yeah.
gavin (54:00.028)
You're you're you're just you're just taking a trip with somebody that you don't really know that much about. you know, are they qualified to be a guide? There's a lot of different levels in terms of what people are teaching and guiding and you know, bringing their students into.
Malin Lobb (54:06.209)
Yeah, and like for most federations.
Malin Lobb (54:17.643)
Yeah, and what's strange to me is that like there are some organized federations in paragliding that it's like it takes you a year or two to become an instructor to teach like people to, you know, jump off the hill and, you know, to take off and land. But your mate down the pub can have a few beers and be like, I'm going to teach Civ and they can. So it's like there's more of a block to, you know, there's
gavin (54:39.481)
Yeah, exactly. I mean anybody can do it.
Malin Lobb (54:43.521)
Yeah, there's more of a block to becoming an instructor than there is to being an SIV instructor and I think it's a much more difficult thing to do well.
gavin (54:53.131)
Mm. Mm. another good one here. And we're we're jumping ship a little bit on what we've been talking about, but how do we protect ourselves from risk homeostasis as we gain skills in wing control and navigating the XC landscape? Do we have to set our limits at the beginning of our careers and stick to them? Otherwise, if we don't, the normal path is fly hotter wings in gnarlier conditions, is we gain skills and experience which erodes our margins.
Malin Lobb (55:22.943)
Yeah, so I think we need to change. So with Active Air, we're doing a monthly podcast and I actually talk about this in the podcast we just released. So I go into too much detail about this, but we need to change as a community of like, like I don't agree with that statement because like currently in our community, getting better is seen as like with the wing being open.
So when the wing is open, the knowledge you learn from the books and the things you learn by coring better and like making these movements smoother and more efficient leads to, okay, you fly 100K, 150, 200K, now that he's a good pilot, but you might have the same wing control as a beginner that's just done an SIV. So we need to see that the two paths are equally as important. So when you look at it from that way,
It's not just, you're getting on a hotter ship, so you're increasing your risk level, or you're into more, in more thermo care, so you're increasing your risk level. If you are becoming a better pilot, as you go, as you make those steps, you can actually be a safer pilot than the guy that's on an ENA that's going into thermo care but has no idea. For me, that's the most dangerous part of your flying.
Because I can take an ENA, a low B, over the lake and I can get END collapses out of it all day long. Just by doing the wrong thing, slightly different kink angle, slightly different movement with my body, a little pump here, phoom, violent results. and I talked about this I think last time, I talk about it a lot, that END test is a test of conformity with a certain kink angle, with the pilot doing a certain thing, you get this result. Outside of that, it's not the wings fault.
It can do vastly different things. So when you become a good pilot, a good pilot on an END wing is never going to let it have an END collapse. It's just not, you're not going to let the flying side shoot and do the 360 and the whatever the test is. You're just going to do that. And it's going to be an ENA collapse. So, and then, you know, more thermic conditions doesn't mean more collapses because you're going to get better at stopping collapses.
gavin (57:28.827)
Yep.
Malin Lobb (57:37.231)
So might be a good pilot can be in five, six meters a second, banging day, really pushing the bar. You know, when we're racing, you can be in those conditions, boom boom, and you don't have a collapse all day. And you can get someone on a low B that's like having a collapse and not even moving their hand. And they're in like two meters a second, just bimbling around. So I think if you do go down the path of hotter wing, more thermic conditions, and you're not increasing your wing control,
along with it, then for sure you're increasing your risk. Because these wings that have more energy, if that energy goes untapped, it has more energy. If you get a wing with more energy and you realise the energy is in your brakes, then you don't need to let it have its full energy ever. It doesn't need to come with 100 % energy because you can be like, nope. Whereas if you're on a B and you don't use the brake range, it can come with more energy than you've ever imagined. If you get a little whip effect or
gavin (58:17.519)
Mm.
gavin (58:28.655)
Mm-hmm.
Malin Lobb (58:36.312)
you're in something violent. So for me, the beauty of higher rate, I would always rather fly a more aggressive, a wing with more energy, a wing with more sniff ability, with more feedback because I can handle that. I want that feedback. want that, you know, I want to be able to turn a wing with a small amount of break range and like light pressure rather than being like down here on a potato, you know, getting like arm pump.
So I want all of those like nice things that come with a hot wing but then you need the skills to fly it. basically just get good at wind control. Like you can't be too good at that and then what it does is it opens up a whole plethora of toys where you can choose your toy depending on what you want from it.
gavin (59:24.627)
Mm. Yeah, I when I read that question, it's a great question. I w when I read that question, I I just i instantly went, I I'm safer on my hotter wing. I I have more margin. I I can get out of stuff, I can deal with wind, I got a better glide, I'm gonna arrive higher, everything is better. I d I y I don't take collapses. Period. I don't even need to knock on wood. I'm not I I I can keep it open all the time. I that that's my passive safety. I don't I don't need to go down to a lower wing to get more passive safety. That that's
Malin Lobb (59:44.044)
Yeah.
Malin Lobb (59:49.655)
Yeah.
gavin (59:54.415)
work in the the wrong direction.
Malin Lobb (59:56.567)
Yeah, and also once you become a good pilot, passive safety goes out window because you're not passive. You know, you do the right thing, you know?
gavin (01:00:01.754)
Right. Nailed it. Very good way to articulate this. Okay, good friend of ours, Misha Banks, who's a a very good instructor out in Colorado, out in Boulder, he said he said folks heard in in air quotes, flat turns are best and using outside rear riser will flatten a thermal turn. Unfortunately newer pilots are stalling out of their turns. So I guess the question is to clarify, should we use outside rear ri riser to flatten turns?
Malin Lobb (01:00:32.236)
Yeah, so when this became a thing, was quite a few years ago now probably, I saw no advantage in comps. People started to do it holding on the outside in weak conditions and I would be thermaling with them and I tried it and I didn't like the, it's a little bit less controlled, especially on the end zones and high aspect ratio where the tip can move independently. I felt like I just better authority not doing it.
I didn't see that like, that person's doing it and now he's climbing better. There seemed to be no advantage to it. So it's more about like how you're feeling, but it was never about like pulling the bee necessarily. It was about like, you you're controlling the outside with it, but it's not like you're like, I'm going to keep this break on and then really pull that one to flatten it out. We'll just release that one and release that one a bit, you know? But yeah, I didn't feel like it gave me as precise control. Now you're
causing less drag maybe, so that might be an advantage, but I never saw that advantage or that perceived less drag actually made people climb better or not. I mean, you've done enough comps, you've probably seen the same thing. Some people do it, some people don't. It's not like they're out climbing you.
gavin (01:01:46.981)
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, I just I don't like the feel of it. I was actually just doing it. I was down to Mexico this last week at the SRS. I hadn't flown a seawing since twenty eleven, so that was that was quite interesting. I would call it quite dull, actually, but they probably don't want me repeating that. But it was I I I saw quite a few people doing that. Like PAL Tackets was was doing it and so I was trying it and I I don't know, I'd I've I think I've just gotten so used to not doing that. But yeah, I don't I don't see really much advantage.
Malin Lobb (01:01:59.417)
Yeah.
Malin Lobb (01:02:12.088)
Yeah. I think if there was a performance advantage, everyone would be doing it. And I haven't seen one, so it's a personal preference.
gavin (01:02:18.586)
Yeah, right. Yep. we were doing a lot this next question also relates to this last week. We were doing a lot of really tight ridge running, super fun, down in Topalpa's an area that I'd I'd never flown in. It was an area that most people hadn't flown in it's not a new spot, it's been around forever, but for comps. And people were talking about speed bar and brake use, which I found kinda interesting.
I we've heard the adage never use brakes when you're on s on bar 'cause it makes the wing go funky. just talk about that. B's versus brakes and speed bar.
Malin Lobb (01:03:00.364)
Yeah, so as you progress in flying and you get better at active flying and like, ooh, there's a pressure drop, you know, any pressure drop, you should be on it. And when that starts to become ingrained in you, if you're using the speed bar and you have the brakes in your hand and you feel a pressure drop, you're gonna do your natural instinct of trying to find that pressure and you will cause the collapse. So anytime you go on bar, even if it's like you've never used the bar before and then tomorrow is the first time you use it, grab the rear risers.
even on your ENA, just get something in your hands that isn't the brakes. Like you keep the brakes around your hands and just grab the rear risers. Now like mid Bs, they've got like rear handles, but make sure it's just not the brakes because if you start to have this natural instinct of like, pressure drop, and you pull the brake wheel bar, for sure you're gonna get a collapse. You you're getting closer and closer to your maximum angle of attack and the brakes cause lift at the back of the wing and it will force it over that.
gavin (01:03:55.355)
Mm-hmm.
Malin Lobb (01:03:59.119)
like getting close to your maximum angle of attack. yeah, I say always have something in your hand. Now with two liners and the range they've got, that's the beauty of two liners and the safety. I, as soon as you can get on a two liner, because now there's no difference between three liners and two liners. It doesn't, there's no like difference in terms of safety or anything. There are some really soft two liners and then some quite punchy aggressive three liners. So now actually the
The crossover is even like you can be on a safer two-liner than you are than some punchy three liners But unless you looked up and counted the lines like you wouldn't know it's not like you're suddenly like this is a two-liner feeling It's like aspect ratio makes more, you know, is the diff the different trator there But for sure if I was on speed bar I would always choose a two-liner over a three-liner because you have much more range of motion of
gavin (01:04:56.58)
On the bees. Yeah. Yeah.
Malin Lobb (01:04:56.814)
collapses on the bees yeah yeah for sure so that's my advice on when you're on bar get something else in your hands like get the rear risers get the bees yeah just don't have them in your because even if you're like I'm not gonna pull a bag and then you get a pressure drop for sure if you're a decent pilot you're gonna try and refine that pressure without even thinking about it and then that's gonna cause the collapse so
gavin (01:05:05.798)
Stay off the brakes. Get away from the brakes. No brakes.
gavin (01:05:18.384)
Yep. Great. two liner recovery difficulty versus three liner, e.g. low C gliders, or it is it really just aspect ratio that matters?
Malin Lobb (01:05:29.932)
Yeah, so like I said, there's no difference now. And there's a crossover of like some pretty nice mellow two-liner Cs, like the Nova Codex and Vortex was like soft. The way it stalled was like more like a B wing. Now with the Ozone, the Delta and the Alpina, beautiful wings, like nice and solid, very easy to fly.
Yeah I notice no difference in the recovery it's you know it's just a few lines. What I do notice with EMBs actually there is a little bit of a problem with the hybrid three two-liner bees is they tend to be a little bit more cravatti with no benefit really because you've still got the three liners at the center you've still got a restricted range of movement when you're on bar but you have a wing that then will cravat like a two-liner so it's a
I would prefer that didn't happen. And then the thing is the less lines you have the more cravat happy a wing potentially is because you get a collapse there's just more gaps between so it's more efficient you get better into wind penetration but if you get a collapse it's more likely that something's going to get stuck in a bigger gap.
gavin (01:06:36.91)
Usually.
gavin (01:06:45.968)
Yep. Yep.
gavin (01:06:51.022)
I haven't thought about it that way. okay, we're getting towards the end here. Effect of glider size on workload and stability, assuming the difference in performance is a given. What has been seen in SIV and in the wild and how to think about risk and difficulty of smaller versus larger sizes and XC conditions?
Malin Lobb (01:07:11.342)
Yeah, the smaller you go the more more aggressive more twitchy. It's just That's how it is less performance more aggression great. Sorry. Sorry small people and I'm one of them, you know, like I I put on weight to get back on the medium Enzo and then I thought yeah, it was a bit of a dirty bulk. I didn't feel particularly healthy So I lost it all again and then I got into running so I went from like 78 kilos and quite okay on the medium Enzo down to like 65 and
gavin (01:07:17.84)
Just how it is. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Malin Lobb (01:07:41.552)
even to get on the small was a bit of ballast but to get back on the medium was like 43 kilos or something which took the fun out of it so you know I've played with my weight to get on different wings but I noticed like the small Enzo for me it's the nicest wing I've ever flown it's beautiful at turning but it's you can tell it's just a little bit more punchy and the medium is everything's a bit softer not quite as nice in the turn but the performance is much better.
And then I see it in CIV, if a new wing comes out and I have someone, I'm like, this wing's a little bit fruity, but it will be the small version. And then someone will come along with the ML or the large, and it's a completely different thing. then harness-wing combo is way more of a thing than the size. So what you're pairing that wing with makes, for me, more of a difference than the size of it. As you get smaller, they can be a bit more aggressive. But even a bigger wing with a, you know,
unstable harness can then be very different to something else with a different harness.
gavin (01:08:45.425)
Mal and last one and I don't I don't have this in front of me. It's an email that came in while I was on my trip and I it deserves more thought than I'd given it, so I haven't answered him, but he's a very new pilot. He's just been listening to the podcast. He's I think he's taken his first couple lessons and because he's listening to the podcast a lot, he's hearing a lot of talk about risk and accidents and th all the things we talk about here, right?
And he's going, God, is this even something I should get into? By coincidence, later today I'm talking to Julian Garcia, the coach, instructor and French team, and he's just released this online book about safety and I I'm I'm only in about a third of the way into it. But it's got some you know he starts off with we have very, very, very bad data. You know, we don't we don't collect data very well.
Malin Lobb (01:09:28.377)
Hmm.
gavin (01:09:40.838)
all the different organizations collect it differently. We sometimes don't collect it at all. So w we we've known we've had this problem. We are we are not the FAA, right? We're not we're not like airplanes. We're we're doing a very d bad job of collecting data. I think often we're trying to solve problems that don't have a pro that aren't problems because we don't have data. But anyway, all that leaving all that aside, some of the statistics that he's been able to gather are really terrifying. and this is
not exactly right 'cause I don't have it in front of me, but it's something along the lines of if you fly for ten years, you've got a twenty five percent chance of a really serious injury or death. twenty years it goes up to fifty percent. Thirty years it's seventy five percent. So seventy five you thirty years you fly, you're gonna have a seventy five percent. Three out of four of us are going to have a bad accident. and so he his question was and and again again this is not with perfect data, but that's about where it comes in.
Malin Lobb (01:10:28.793)
Yeah.
gavin (01:10:37.317)
So his question is, you know, should I even do this? You know, are and so the question is, are we completely kidding ourselves? I mean back to this you know, the the theme of this talk was misconceptions. You know, are we is it a complete misconception that we could get through this unscathed?
Malin Lobb (01:10:40.761)
Mm.
Malin Lobb (01:10:56.291)
Yeah, I think that's a really interesting question and I am exactly the same as you is that I am about a third of the way through Julian's book at the moment and there is something that well it would actually be good if you you pose the question to him but it is that I don't think we're all in the same boat so I don't think it's that like this is like all paragliding pilots and we are all as likely to have a fatal accident.
I really don't think that's true. And the other thing is, from what I read is that, know, that, yeah, the blame is on the pilot and it shouldn't be. I would argue that like certain things should in the, if let's imagine tomorrow, no one ever rotated into the ground again. So that everyone flying was just an absolute master of rotations and that whatever configuration they got into, boom, they would just stop a rotation.
our death rate would just go down massively. Like dying on a paraglider is so easy if you're in a rotation. If you're in some sort of stool configuration, it's much less likely. If you're in straight flight, you might break an ankle. It's very hard to die in a straight flight, regardless of what you, well, I suppose if you crashed into a cliff and you're high potentially, but do you know what I mean? so rotations are the biggest killer in our sport.
gavin (01:12:17.723)
Yeah, yeah, no, it it it's it's rot every death I've seen has been because people are spiralling into the ground.
Malin Lobb (01:12:24.449)
Exactly and for me I would say like unless you're like super twisted or whatever but then again getting into that configuration usually is a lack of pilot skill. I would say if everyone mastered rotations and was just on it like because we let the wing go from above our head into a rotation we let it happen. It's not like and Russ said this before and like I say all the time an auto rotation means it happens automatically without pilot input.
If you do a pilot input, you don't have to let it go into a rotation. If no pilot from this day forth let their glider rotate them to the ground, death rate would go down. Right? I'm sure of it. I would put money on it. So that is my question is that there's so many nuances to why accidents happen. You know, like the Swiss cheese thing of like, it's not one thing, it's multiple. There's the, don't know what you don't know. There's how humans behave under stress.
there's in our flying, it's very like, it's accepted that people get good at flying when their wings open, but can be terrible when it's SIV is not mandatory. If it was, that would probably put as many people off as not because SIV is not regulated. Like it's a shambles at the moment. Like, so I can't say that SIV should be regulated because then it's good, you you'll have loads more people doing bad SIVs that might put them off or they might not learn something or.
gavin (01:13:44.123)
Mm-hmm.
Malin Lobb (01:13:51.436)
or even worse, they have that exposure and think they've learned something but actually not be able to put it into real life situations. there's no easy answer to it, but I would say that if everyone was just like bomb on it, like I'm never gonna let a glider take me from being above my head to being more than like here in a rotation. I'm definitely never gonna let it go to like nose down ever.
So the chances of me being one of that pool of like, we're all paragliding pilots. I think there's a group of pilots here. Like you don't hear all the time of like, that test pilot died and like, you know, all the guys at the top like Ono, Russ, like all those guys, yeah, no, he died recently. It's not this group of pilots. So I do think like...
you might move out of the kind of like, this is the accident statistics. And that doesn't mean that tomorrow it might not happen and we are not immune from it because there's always that red zone. There's always in aviation, always a possibility tomorrow I might go for a hike and fly and die. Like that is just the risk we take. But I would put my chances on a group of pilots that's like good at wind control. I would say they're probably not the ones that are gonna.
And that's why most people die on ENA and B gliders. It's not the guys on the hot ships that are, and you could say there's statistically a lot less of them, but actually now that the sport is older and older and people are building up more and more hours, I think now there's a lot more people on the higher end wings than there was 10, 15 or so years ago. So yeah, I don't think we can all be put in the same basket and I don't.
gavin (01:15:23.012)
Mm. Mm.
Same bucket.
Malin Lobb (01:15:28.597)
yeah the same bucket and I do think that actually pilot skill does come into the seriousness of the injuries in terms of letting a glider rotate when you don't need it to.
gavin (01:15:42.931)
You know what was scary about the the book the the portion I'm in was I I didn't realize there were so many accidents at the really early stage. I I'm I'm talking like tandems and instruction, you know, at schools. that's horrifying. That's that's bad schooling.
Malin Lobb (01:15:52.749)
Mm.
Malin Lobb (01:15:57.988)
Yeah.
Malin Lobb (01:16:02.839)
Yeah, well, and actually here there was two deaths with the pitch, like the the porpoising within two years. So they banned it from from beginning teaching. I'd already stopped doing it in Civ. Like I don't teach pitch like this because I saw that the benefit of learning pitch that way, like the danger compared to the benefit.
gavin (01:16:17.522)
No.
Malin Lobb (01:16:24.995)
which there was just a massive imbalance. And then also of that maneuver, say that you have to do like five pitch pendulums and build them just to get one catch. It means that like 90 % of what you're trying to teach them is irrelevant because you're trying to teach them after the bottom of the pendulum as the glider's climbing to do an input, which unless you're going to do like a misty or something, you never do in your flying. So you're doing an input that you're never having to do. And then when they get it slightly wrong and their body's just starting to descend and they do a wrong timed input,
They just like skid off all that pitch. Whereas if you just do a bit of a turn, put your hand up and like compensate, you have the same dive, but with way less risk exposure. And it's like, you haven't had to like do all this and a complicated thing just to catch. But you can just go in, compensate and there's the dive that you need to catch. So you can learn pitch without exposing that whip effect. So what caused people to die was that the gliders behind them, they were a bit too aggressive. The glider.
the kind of stools and then they have the whip which then means they get gift wrapped. So like the potential to get it wrong is like massive, you know it's like gift wrap time just to learn pitch when you can learn it in a much easier less technical way. So yeah I haven't taught pitch that way in years.
gavin (01:17:29.886)
They don't catch it and they go in the wing.
gavin (01:17:41.848)
Wow. Huh. Amazing. Huh. Excellent. Mallon, thanks, man. You're a gem. we didn't get to talk about your new endeavor and and you're you know, you've split away from from Fly Yo. So we'll put that in the
Malin Lobb (01:17:57.315)
Mm-hmm.
gavin (01:17:58.664)
put that in the post what you're up to and what's happening in your world and I know we're gonna do another one of these with your great video series and all that stuff coming out too. So we'll we'll we'll dive into that with Pure and Active Air.
Malin Lobb (01:18:12.791)
Yep, cool. Nice to chat as always. It's been like six years since the first one. That's crazy.
gavin (01:18:14.152)
Very man.
gavin (01:18:19.014)
Wow, dude, no wonder I'm getting so gray. I'm looking at myself here going, Jeez, I to shave, I'm getting awful grey Yeah, I know. It's it's amazing. Well you're you're great. I mean one of the questions I got was when are we gonna get you over to the States and what does that look like and how can we how can we do it? How can we get you over here? So maybe I can be the maybe I can be the catalyst in making that happen. I know that people would be really psyched and not have to travel all the way to Europe, but maybe we can get you over here for some fun.
Malin Lobb (01:18:24.377)
Yeah.
Malin Lobb (01:18:43.443)
I have a lot of clients that come over and I say to them like if you can set something up I'll be there in a heartbeat so I just need a toe operation I just need a lake and I'll turn up with a kit and I'm ready to go so like I'm ready.
gavin (01:18:55.199)
Well that I I I know all those guys over here, so we'll we'll try to make that happen. That'd be great. Awesome, man. Thanks, Mallon. Appreciate it. All right, bud. Cheers. Bye. wait a minute. There we go.
Malin Lobb (01:19:00.815)
That'd be cool. All right, good to chat. Cheers.